The week it all clicks is the one where the morning is properly cold, you can see your breath at the bus stop, but by two o'clock the sun's out and you're sweating in the coat you grabbed on instinct. That's the whole point of a casual autumn outfit, something you can peel layers off through the day without ending up carrying half of it in a bag. It's the first proper knit over a shirt, the jeans that have gone back into rotation after months of bare legs, the jacket that's heavier than a cardigan but not yet a proper winter coat. That stretch from late September through to November is when this sort of dressing earns its keep, if you'll forgive me, because nothing else in the year asks you to layer quite so cleverly.
Before you buy anything in this bracket, check the weight of the knit against what you'll actually wear under it, because a chunky jumper over a shirt with a collar that won't lie flat is a daily irritation, not a one off. Look at how a jacket sits when there's a jumper underneath it rather than just a t shirt, since a lot of them are cut for the thinner layer and go tight across the shoulders the second fifty grams of wool gets added. Zips, poppers and toggles are worth a tug in the shop, not just a look, because the cheap ones jam within a fortnight. On the clashing side, a heavy cable knit and a stiff structured jacket fight each other for bulk, so pick one chunky piece per outfit and keep the rest slim. Don't put autumn's muddy palette, the rust, the khaki, the oatmeal, against anything too crisp and summery, like a bright white trainer that's clearly been nowhere near wet pavement. Straight leg or slightly wide jeans sit better under a longer jumper than skinny ones do, which bunch at the ankle and make the whole thing look unfinished. For fit, buy the knitwear slightly roomier than you think, since it needs to go over something, and check jacket sleeves aren't so long they get wet dragging through puddles, which happens more than you'd expect once the leaves come down.
This is school run, market trip, long walk with a flask weather, not an evening out.
Dressed right, it makes the coat you already own look like you planned the whole thing on purpose.