Classy used to mean one thing on the high street: a shift dress, court shoes, maybe a strand of pearls if you were feeling bold. That version has loosened up a lot, and for the better. Now it covers tailored trousers with a good shirt, a slip skirt with flat boots, a sharp blazer over almost anything, which means you can build it from pieces that already earn their place rather than buying one stiff outfit for a single purpose.
The thing that undoes it fastest is piling on too many "statement" ideas at once, a bold print with a fussy shoe and a bag with hardware on it, so the eye doesn't know where to land. Smart separates want one focal point and everything else to behave. It also clashes with anything too tightly fitted and too shiny in the same breath, satin and spandex together tip straight into occasionwear rather than classy daywear, which is a different job entirely. And honestly, this whole category can be the wrong choice if you actually need to move, crouch, carry things, or sit on a train floor with a toddler, structured tailoring has no give in it and will remind you of that within the hour.
Fit is where most of this either works or doesn't, and the shop checks are simple. On a blazer, the shoulder seam should sit exactly on your shoulder bone, not hanging off it like a borrowed coat, and you should be able to raise both arms without the whole back pulling up out of your waistband. On trousers, check the rise sitting down as well as standing, and look at the back for pulling lines across the seat, that's not your shape being wrong, that's the cut being wrong. Skirts and dresses in structured fabric need room to sit without the hem riding or the waist digging, do a proper sit test in the changing room, not a glance in the mirror standing up straight with your stomach pulled in like you're having a passport photo taken.
If you're starting from nothing, go for a blazer first, it does more jobs than any other single piece here, worn open over a plain top and jeans on an ordinary day, or buttoned over trousers when you need to look like you've got your life together. Everything else can follow once you know how that one piece behaves on you.
For a first one, I'd choose navy over black. It reads just as smart, photographs softer, and doesn't show every mark the way black does by the end of a long day.