I was crammed into the backseat of my boss’s Uber on our way to a client presentation, doing my best to keep my knees from bumping the ceiling while also trying not to let my feet slip into the dome created by my thighs that ride share drivers clearly assume all passengers fit into. I’m 5’7”, by the way. No amount of thighs should create that much interior elevator shaft in an Uber.

My shoes were stuffed under my seat in the futile attempt to keep them from sliding around inside the aforementioned hobbit hole when Sarah whipped her head down to look at them. “What are those?” she asked, eyeing my loafers incredulously. Sarah will be the first to tell you that she loves a good designer shoe. She caught our summer associate wearing a fake Hermès belt last summer – didn’t say anything, but she seemed to spend the entire meeting performing surgery on it with her eyebrows.

The kid started wearing canvas belts for the remainder of his internship, which was probably for the best. “These? They’re from Target,” I replied, steeling myself for the ensuing lecture about investment shoes and cost-per-wear she inevitably launches into whenever I openly wear something she knows didn’t break the bank. “Wait what?” Sarah whipped her ankle around so she could tug my shoe closer to her face. “The brown ones with the gold accents?

You paid how much for these?” I nodded, and she immediately whipped out her phone to navigate Target’s website on our ride downtown. “Don’t tell me your size, Lauren, I’m getting them in every color.

You’ll wear them to the Morrison meeting next week, I just know it.” And just like that, my $25 shoe purchase had become insider office knowledge. Let me preface this by saying I love a good designer shoe as much as the next girl – finance people have to look put-together without trying TOO hard, and shoes are where most people start. The only problem is that you’re also constantly on your feet in our line of work, walking from meeting to meeting and basically living in your office elevator.

You need something comfortable enough to actually get through the day – and these somehow deliver. I originally purchased these chocolate brown Universal Thread loafers on a lunchtime shopping emergency – spare pair for work, in case you couldn’t guess. When I got to work that day, they had received compliments from two separate people who were actually acquainted with the $800 Row loafers that these stupid shoes are apparently the dead ringer for.

Here’s how. As I was rushing out the door to lunch with a client, the heel on my “real” shoe shattered off onto the sidewalk in front of the Federal Reserve. With literally twenty minutes to get downtown, look semi-professional, and make a positive first impression on a client who could impact my bonus, I shoved my designer shoe into my work bag and ran into the nearest Target.

I grabbed the first pair of brown shoes I saw in my size, ran to the bathroom to change, and hoped for the best. I fully expected to wear these once, get the compliments, then pack them off to Goodwill. But they were SO comfortable.

I wore them again the next day, and then again the day after that. Now they’re basically my go-to work shoes. I couldn’t tell you how many times I’ve worn them since that fateful first purchase, but I will say that the first person who wasn’t Sarah to comment on how similar they looked to something way more expensive was my own boss.

We were grabbing drinks after work in SoHo when Mrs. Green herself rounded the corner wearing what was undoubtedly an actual Row shoe sheepskin-ugg-boot-but-make-it-fashion-boot hybrid. I smiled and nodded at her question, carefully angling my feet underneath the table so she couldn’t see my Target sourcing. “Thanks.

They are!” From that point on, I tested the limits. Would someone who worked at Bluestone Jones recognize my impostor shoes for what they were? What about my dad (who knows nothing about fashion)?

Men’s or women’s designer shoes; I ran the gauntlet. Here’s what I found: Men’s designers were by far the easiest to convince. My mom spent at least 10 minutes scrutinizing them over Zoom one morning before asking me if I’d “finally started making enough money that you’re wasting it on menswear?” Meanwhile, my coworkers at Bluestone Jones somehow seemed to know every designer shoe that came in女性らしいけど甘すぎないニットパンツeveryone’s closet – men’s included.

They weren’t fooled, although Sarah still swears she saw some Hollywood director mistake them for the RTichelots at Whole Foods once. Most everyone else I know? Completely stumped.

And here’s the thing – it’s not *just* the style. They’re definitely similar to The Row’s design, sure, but so are a million other faux-Row shoes out there. I think what sets these particular ones apart is how they age.

How My $25 Target Loafers Keep Getting Mistaken for $800 Designer Shoes

Cheap shoes tend to look cheap. These get better with wear, if you dress them right. The leather (also TBH I’m skeptical Universal Thread is using real leather here)softens over time, giving them a rich sheen that actually enhances the “expensive” factor.

After about two months of regular wear, they finally stopped looking brand new and started looking like I actually knew what I was doing when I wore them. Look, I’m no shoe guru. I wore these things because they were comfortable and didn’t break the bank, not because I suddenly became an expert on fashion yourself vs.

RTichelots vs. Coach versus whatever else people think are designer these days. But here’s the thing: the women I know who dress the best don’t wear designer shoes all the time.

They know where to splurge and where to save. They can take a J. Crew dress and make it look like it came from the Nordstrom designer floor.

They’ll throw on a pair of Uniqlo basics with the one perfect vintage blouse they own. Everyone is shocked when I tell them these shoes cost less than my regular weekly lunch shopping budget. In finance, that’s kind of the point.

Not only are they comfortable, but I never fear ruining them the way I do my nicer shoes. I’ve worn them in rainstorms, to wine nights where someone (definitely not me) spilt red wine all over the ground, and once on a Saturday when I had to help my best friend move and forgot to wear sneakers. To say they’ve held up would be an understatement.

There are a couple of downsides, of course.

The insoles aren’t as padded as I prefer, so I had to resort to Target own discounted arch supports to make them bearable on long days. And the interior lining is starting to wear a bit after eight months and many inside caribbean-seasonings.com/pants-out pairs.

But at $25? I can forgive a lot. Last month, I found myself in the middle of a presentation across from the literal Queen of Accessories.

And by queen, I mean a woman who runs accessory buying for a number of luxury companies, Row included. She was perched across from me in AirYaks wearing what can only be described as the Row uniform –neutral-on-neutral, scarf tossed effortlessly over one shoulder, actual Row loafers. Mine mocked me from underneath my chair as we discussed interest rate hikes and market projections.

I couldn’t shake the feeling that she could see them, too, and any second now she was going to realization bell gong the whole conference room into woman who wears $25 shoes buys her fancy suits at TJ Maxx awareness. As she walked by my desk to greet another coworker after the presentation, I braced myself for her colleague to cuff me up like Elaine from Seinfeld. “Love your shoes,” she said without preamble, locking eyes. “Comfortable?” She smiled that smile that old Rich People have when they know you just lied to them about your banking major. All I could muster was a sheepish grin in return. “They really are.”

More style tips

See them all
Esme Varga

Author Esme Varga