I avoided the whole clean girl thing for years because I assumed it meant looking like you'd spent an hour achieving a face with no makeup on it, and I don't have the patience or the bathroom cabinet for that. What changed was realising it's actually just a handful of plain, well cut pieces worn with a bit of restraint, which is something I can manage even on a rushed Tuesday.
The look falls apart fast if you mix in anything too busy. Heavy logos, clashing textures, a statement bag with a statement coat, any of that fights the whole point, which is a sense of calm rather than a pile up of ideas. Stick to one texture doing the talking, a soft knit or a crisp poplin, and let everything else go quiet around it. Jewellery wants the same restraint, one good piece rather than three fighting for attention on the same wrist.
The pieces that make this look work tend to be simple, which also means any flaw in the cut or the fabric shows up immediately, there's nowhere for it to hide. A white shirt or a plain tee in a flattering fabric will soften with washing and start to drape better after a few wears, but a cheap one goes grey and bobbly within a month and suddenly looks like something from a packet of three. Wash things like this on a cooler cycle, turn them inside out, and avoid the tumble dryer if you can, because heat is what kills the crispness that makes a plain piece look expensive rather than basic. Neutral knitwear pills faster than you'd expect if it's rubbed against a bag strap all day, so a small fabric shaver earns its keep here more than almost anywhere else in a wardrobe.
In the shop, before anything goes in the basket, hold the fabric up to the light and check it isn't see through in a way you didn't plan for, that's the first thing that catches people out with pale colours. Run your fingers over a knit and check for any looseness in the weave, a sign it'll stretch out of shape within a few wears. Check seams on trousers and shirts lie flat rather than puckering, since on a plain piece every seam is visible with nothing to distract from it. Try the whole thing under proper light rather than the flattering sort most changing rooms use, because clean, pale colours show up differently depending on what's reflecting off them.
Next time you're looking, check the fabric first, before the cut or the colour, because that's what decides whether the whole thing still looks this calm in six months.
While you're here, don't skip minimalist outfits.