An a line dress is kind to nearly everybody, which is a bold claim and I don't make it lightly. If you carry weight around your middle, it skims rather than clings, and if you're straight up and down, it gives you a shape you didn't have twenty minutes ago. The only people who should think twice are anyone who wants to show off a waist they're proud of that day, because an a line dress is deliberately vague about where your waist actually is. That's the trade off. Comfort for definition.
What I like is how little it asks of the rest of your wardrobe. A plain a line in a decent colour goes under a denim jacket for the school run, under a blazer for something that needs to look a bit more sorted, or on its own with trainers when it's warm and you can't be bothered with anything else. I've got one I've worn with flat boots and tights through most of a grim February, then again with bare legs and sandals the first warm weekend, and it didn't look like the same dress either time, which is the whole point of the shape. It doesn't fight with cardigans either, which matters more than people admit once autumn turns.
The difference between a good one and a bad one shows up in about thirty seconds of wear. Cheap ones use a fabric with no weight to it, so the skirt doesn't swing, it just sort of hangs there and clings to tights with static. A proper one has a bit of body in the cloth, enough that the skirt moves when you walk instead of following your legs around like it owes you money. Check the seams at the waist, that's where the shape actually comes from, and a bad seam there will pull or pucker within a few washes. Zips matter too. A side zip that's been put in straight sits flat under a coat, a crooked one announces itself every time you sit down.
For colour, I'd always point someone towards navy, a soft green, or a plain black before anything with a print, not because prints are wrong but because a plain a line in a colour you already wear does more jobs without you thinking about it. Rust and burgundy are forgiving too, and hide a multitude of sins on a dress you'll wear on repeat.
Given time, the good ones soften. The fabric loses its stiffness, the skirt swings a little looser, and it stops looking new in a way that actually suits the shape, it starts looking like something you own rather than something you bought.
Silk dresses are worth a look too.