The thing nobody tells you about burgundy is that it doesn't photograph the way it wears. In pictures it looks almost black, moody and safe, then you get it under proper daylight or restaurant lighting and it's got this red undertone that warms up your whole face in a way navy and black never do. That only becomes obvious after you've worn it a good few times, in different light, at different times of day.
Where it comes unstuck is next to other reds and anything orange toned, mustard especially, it all starts fighting for attention and you end up looking like you got dressed in a rush. Pair it with black, with grey, with camel or with denim instead and it calms right down. It's at its best from October through to around February, dinners, work parties, anywhere you want to look a bit more done than your usual black dress without going full red carpet, and it carries into spring surprisingly well under a denim jacket, when everyone else is still in florals and you look like you've thought about it.
Fabric is where the good ones and the sad ones split off completely. A burgundy made in a jersey with a bit of weight to it, or a crepe, holds the colour properly and drapes instead of clinging in the wrong places. Cheap polyester satin finishes are the trap, they catch the light in a way that looks slightly cheap under any kind of flash, and the colour often skews more pink than burgundy once you're outside the shop. Check the seams too, burgundy shows puckering and loose threads more than black does because the colour isn't as forgiving, so run your thumb along the inside seams before you buy. Lining matters as well, a dress with even a basic lining sits better and doesn't go see through the first time you're stood near a window.
Washing is the other thing people get wrong. Burgundy bleeds more than almost any other dark colour in the first few washes, so cold water, inside out, and never with anything pale unless you want a faint pink tinge on your white t-shirts, which I did find out the hard way. After that it settles and holds its colour for ages, better than a lot of blacks actually, which fade to grey long before burgundy fades to anything.
It's a colour that does more flattering work than black ever will, and once you've worn a good one you stop reaching for black automatically.