The question I get asked most is whether a holiday dress is just a summer dress with a better suntan, and the honest answer is no, not quite. A holiday dress has to survive a suitcase, a sweaty airport, and three outfit changes a day without ironing, which is a different job to looking nice for one wedding in June.
The difference between a good one and a disappointing one shows up fast once you've worn it. A well made holiday dress is cut from something that doesn't cling when you're warm, cotton, linen, a proper viscose, not a thin polyester that goes see through the second you step into sunlight and clings to the back of your thighs on a plastic sunlounger. The seams matter more than people expect on something this casual, because a cheap side seam will twist after one hand wash and sit crooked across your hip for the rest of the trip. Check what's happening at the bust too. Loose, floaty dresses are brilliant until the neckline gapes forward every time you lean over a menu, and a lot of the high street ones do exactly that because the shoulder seam sits too wide. Elastic waists are forgiving after a big lunch, which is the whole point of a holiday, but a cheap elastic will have given up by day four of hand washing in a hotel sink, so check it's got some actual bounce back before you buy, not just stretch.
Where this dress earns its place is obvious, poolside, dinner on a terrace, the airport itself if you're sensible about it, any point between May and September when you want to look dressed without trying. It's also quietly good at covering sunburn you're embarrassed about and sand you haven't fully brushed off, which nobody tells you is half the appeal. Where it falls apart is anywhere the weather turns or the occasion gets formal. A thin cotton dress with spaghetti straps is miserable the second there's a breeze off the sea at nine in the evening, and it will not do a wedding, a smart dinner, or an office, no matter how nice the print is. I've worn one to a leaving do once out of sheer packing laziness and spent the whole night cold and slightly underdressed.
Look first at how it sits across the back and shoulders when you lift your arms, because that's where a badly cut one gives itself away before the fabric even gets a chance to.