The question I get asked most about one shoulder dresses is whether they actually stay up, because everyone's convinced they're one deep breath away from disaster. The honest answer is that a well cut one stays exactly where it should, and a badly cut one needs constant adjusting from the moment you leave the house to the moment you get home.
Where this shape falls down for me is anything that involves a lot of movement without a mirror nearby, a long day at a desk, or a bra situation that isn't already sorted, because the strapless bra underneath is doing more work than the dress fabric itself and a cheap one will slide within the hour. It's also not kind to a very structured, boxy top half, since the asymmetry wants a bit of natural shape to sit against rather than fight. On colour, I've learned to stop reaching for the loud botanical prints that look brilliant on a hanger and useless on an actual body, because the single strap draws the eye straight to whatever pattern is happening at the shoulder and a busy one makes you look like you're wearing a flag. Solid colour is far easier to live with. Deep berry, bottle green, a proper black, even a strong cobalt, these hold their shape and don't fight with the asymmetry the way a print does. A cheap one in any of these colours still looks cheap close up, mind you, the seam at the shoulder puckers, the fabric goes slightly see through under certain lights, and you can see where corners were cut around the one place that's meant to hold the whole dress together. A better made version has a proper boned or lined panel through the bodice, so the weight sits on your ribs rather than entirely on that one strap, which is the difference between wearing it comfortably and holding your stomach in all night out of fear.
Fabric matters more here than almost any other dress shape, because there's less structure overall to disguise a bad one. A stiff polyester will crease the second you sit down and never quite recover, while a good crepe or a proper jersey blend moves with you and drops back into place. Over several wears a decent one keeps its line at the shoulder instead of stretching and slipping lower with every wash, though I'd still hand wash or use a delicate bag on cool rather than risk the machine mangling that single strap. Hang it rather than fold it, because folding tends to crease exactly where you don't want a crease, right across the chest.
Mine has softened a touch with age, the fabric a little more fluid than it was, the shoulder seam sitting slightly lower than it did new, but it still holds its shape rather than giving up entirely, which is really all you can ask of it.
If you're building a look, off shoulder dresses will help.