A velvet dress is the one that makes you look dressed without any extra effort going into it. It carries a room on its own, so you can wear plain shoes and a coat you've had for years and still feel like you made a decision getting ready. That's the job it does: evenings, family gatherings, the kind of occasion where jeans feel wrong but a full outfit feels like too much admin.
Fit is where velvet catches people out, because the fabric has a bit of weight and no give to speak of, so anything snug when you try it on will feel snug all night. Go for the size you'd normally take rather than sizing down for the stretch you think velvet has, because it mostly doesn't. Pay attention to the bust and underarm first, that's where a cheap cut pulls and shows a line across the chest when you sit down, and check the hem doesn't ride up at the back when you walk, which happens more than you'd expect on dresses with any kind of wrap or gather. If you can, sit in it before you buy it. A dress that looks perfect standing at a mirror and then creases and tightens across the lap the second you're in a chair is not a dress you want to be wearing for three hours.
The difference between a good one and a disappointing one is mostly in the pile and the lining. Cheap velvet goes flat and shiny at the seat and elbows within a few wears, and it often feels slightly stiff rather than soft, like it's sitting on top of you rather than moving with you. A better one has a bit of weight to the drape, keeps its colour depth in different light rather than going patchy, and is properly lined so the inside doesn't drag against tights. Check the zip too, a decent concealed one at the side rather than a cheap exposed zip up the back that catches on everything.
For pairing, I keep it simple. A longline cardigan or a plain coat over the top, boots rather than strappy sandals, and jewellery that's either gone entirely or just one thing, because the fabric itself is already doing plenty. If you're buying your first one, go for a simple shape in a dark colour rather than anything fitted and bright. Black, bottle green or deep burgundy in a straightforward midi will get more wear than a bold colour cut close to the body, and it won't date the way a trend shape will.
Steam it rather than iron it, because direct heat will flatten the pile and you won't get it back.
A lot of people browsing here also like lace dresses.