A good beanie is wool, not acrylic, and that decision is really made for you before you've tried a single one on. Acrylic looks identical on the shelf, sits identical on your head, and then the first proper shower comes along and it goes damp and lifeless in a way wool simply doesn't.
I'd stick to the colours that don't ask anything of you. Oatmeal, charcoal, a navy that's nearly black, a deep bottle green if you want a little more character without it reading as a statement. These sit happily under a coat hood, over a plait, next to almost any scarf you own, and they don't argue with the rest of what you're wearing the way a mustard or a bright red one will after the novelty wears off. Lambswool is lovely against the skin and keeps its shape well. Merino is finer, softer on bare ears, and better if yours are sensitive to wool generally, though it's a touch less hard wearing at the fold if you're forever pulling it on and off. Cashmere blends are a genuine pleasure to own but I'd want a higher percentage of something sturdier mixed in, because pure cashmere on a hat that gets handled, stuffed in a coat pocket and sat on at least twice a week doesn't keep its shape half as well as people expect. For everyday wear, a beanie earns its outings under a wool coat or an anorak, with a jumper in a related but not matching shade, and it's one of the few accessories that looks exactly as good with trainers as it does with boots.
Over a winter and into the next, the fold is where you'll see any weakness first, a cuff that's lost its bounce, or bobbling right where your hand grips it to pull it on. Decent wool resists that for a long time. Wash it by hand or on a wool cycle, lay it flat to dry rather than hanging it, which stretches the crown, and give it a gentle once over with a fabric comb if it starts to pill, which even good wool will eventually do and isn't a sign of anything gone wrong. If you've none at all, start with a plain lambswool one in charcoal or oatmeal rather than anything patterned or slouchy, since it's the version you'll actually reach for on a wet Wednesday rather than save for best.
Tomorrow morning I'd put the oatmeal one on with a navy coat and leave the scarf loose rather than tucked in.