The question I get most about dark blue jeans is whether they really do go with everything, and the honest answer is almost, not quite. They're the closest denim gets to neutral, which means they'll sit happily under a blazer or a plain jumper, but they still have a mood, and it's a slightly dressed up one compared to anything lighter.
Where they come unstuck is next to anything else trying to make the same point. Pair dark blue jeans with another heavy indigo piece, a jacket or a bag in the same tone, and you end up looking like you got dressed in the dark, two blues fighting for attention instead of one doing its job quietly. They also don't love sitting next to very washed out, pale denim in the same outfit, double denim works far better when the two blues are clearly different depths, not close cousins. And I'd leave them at home for anything that wants real formality, a black tie situation, a solicitor's office, they can edge smart casual but they stop there, and trying to push them further just reads as jeans that know they're jeans.
The difference between a pair that earns its spot on repeat and one that gets worn twice and binned shows up after a few washes, not on the first try on. Cheap dark denim fades at the inner thigh and the backs of the knees within a month, going patchy and a bit grey rather than keeping that even, ink like depth. Good ones use a dye that's actually gone into the yarn properly rather than sitting on the surface, so the colour holds even when you've shoved them in a bag after a gym session and they've sat there creased for three days. Check the weight of the fabric too, anything too thin will bag at the knee by lunchtime, and look at the stitching on the pockets and the fly, if it's already a bit loose on the hanger, it won't survive a season of real wear. The rivets and button should feel solid, not like they'll work themselves loose the first time you sit down on a hard chair.
What they're not good for is trying to look like something else entirely, a jean is a jean, and asking it to do the job of trousers for a formal evening will only disappoint you. For almost everything else, a pair that's kept its colour and its shape after a year of actual wear is one worth holding onto.
Once you're done here, give light blue jeans five minutes.