A good pair of mid rise jeans has a bit of structure to the denim before you even step into them, enough weight that they hold their shape over your hand rather than flopping like a bedsheet. The waistband should feel solid, not flimsy, with stitching that sits flat and a button that feels like it means business. You can tell a lot about how a jean will behave just by how it sits on a hanger.
Mid rise is the one that gets on with almost everything else you own, which is the whole point of it sitting where it does, just below the navel rather than up at the ribs or down at the hip. A fitted jumper tucked in halfway, a plain tee, a blazer thrown over the top for work, none of it fights with the waistband the way high rise sometimes does under certain tops, and none of it leaves the gap at the back that low rise is famous for. The fit itself is where people get caught out. Try sitting down in the changing room, not just standing and admiring yourself in the mirror, because mid rise jeans that look perfect standing can gape at the back waistband the second you sit, especially if they're cut for a flatter seat than you've got. Watch for pulling across the front of the thigh when you bend your knee, that's a sign they're a size too small even if the waist feels right, denim is deceptive like that because it moves differently to how it looks folded on a shelf. The waistband should sit without digging in or needing a constant tug upward, and there should be a little room to breathe after a big lunch, because jeans that are perfect on an empty stomach at eleven in the morning are a different story by three. If you're starting from nothing, go for a straight leg in a mid blue wash with a bit of stretch in the fabric, nothing too dark, nothing too distressed, it's the one that won't look dated in two years and goes under boots or trainers without any fuss.
They get better with time, which is the strange, lovely thing about denim that nothing else in your drawers does quite the same way. The knees soften first, then the fabric starts to give slightly at the hip crease, moulding roughly to how you actually sit and walk, not how the factory imagined you would. A few washes in, the colour mellows just enough to look lived in rather than new, and by the time they're properly broken in they fit better than the day you bought them, which almost makes up for how long that takes.