A good pair of black earrings has a bit of weight to it, even the small ones. You pick it up off the counter and there's a cool, dense little drop in your fingers before it even catches the light, not flashy, just solid. Black doesn't need to shout, so when it's made well it tells you straight away, there's no catch or scratch to the back, the post slides in clean, and the whole thing sits settled rather than swinging about looking for attention.
Worn regularly, black earrings earn their scuffs quietly rather than loudly, a small knock here, a bit of dulling on the edge of a hoop there, and honestly it suits them, black has a way of ageing into something a touch more interesting rather than looking tired. Keep them out of the shower and away from perfume sprayed directly onto the neck, that's what actually dulls a finish faster than anything, and give them a wipe with a soft cloth now and then rather than letting them sit in a dish gathering dust and hairspray. Black earrings are brilliant through fairly grim weather too, the kind of flat grey months when everything else in your coat and jumper combination has gone a bit muted and sad, a sharp black earring is one of the few things that still reads as deliberate rather than just dark. Where they struggle is against anything else black and shiny right at the neckline, a patent collar, a lot of jet buttons, you end up with a sort of competing glare instead of one clean note, so I'd keep the rest of the black nearby matte, or just give the earrings the only shine in the room.
The difference between a pair that lasts and one that's bin bound by March is mostly in what you can't see at first glance. Cheap black finish is usually a coating over a paler metal, and it goes first at the edges, a worn ring of silver or gold peeking through like a bad dye job growing out. A proper one is black through the material itself, or plated thickly enough that it doesn't flake, and the hardware, the hook, the butterfly back, the hinge on a hoop, should feel tight and sprung rather than loose and tinny. Weight tells you a lot too, a drop earring that feels like nothing in your hand usually looks like nothing against your ear, there's no movement, no catch of light, it just hangs there being vaguely dark.
Next time you're looking, run a thumbnail gently along the edge first, if colour comes off under it, put it straight back down.
You might like blue earrings as well.