I spent years thinking stud earrings were what you wore when you'd run out of ideas, the earring equivalent of a plain T-shirt, something to put on when you couldn't be bothered. What changed was losing a drop earring down a drain outside a café and being left with one ear bare for most of a day, and realising how much calmer my face looked with just a small fixed point of light at the lobe and nothing swinging about. I went and bought studs properly the following week and haven't really looked back.
They're not the right choice everywhere, and I'll say that plainly. If you want drama at the ear, a stud won't give it to you, it sits still and small and doesn't catch anyone's attention from across a room, so for anything where you actually want the earring noticed, a proper evening out, a dress with a bare neckline that's crying out for something to balance it, you're better off with a drop or a hoop with some weight to it. Studs are a quiet decision, and worn with the wrong outfit they can look like an afterthought rather than a choice. The difference between a good pair and a bad one shows up fast, though, usually within a week. Cheap studs have thin, slightly bent posts that catch on jumpers, backs that lose their grip after a few goes and leave you patting your ear nervously all evening, and a coating that wears through at the edges so you get a faint green ring if your skin's at all reactive. A well made pair has a post with some actual substance to it, a back that clicks or screws rather than just pushing on with friction, and if there's a stone set into it, the setting sits flush and doesn't snag on hair or scarves. Solid metal, or a decent thickness of plating over a hypoallergenic base, feels obviously different the first time you put them in, even before you've worn them a full day.
They clash with more than you'd expect, mainly anything else fighting for attention near the face. A chunky statement necklace and studs together just looks like you forgot to finish getting dressed, because the necklace needs an earring doing some work too. Big collars, high polo necks and heavy scarves tend to swallow them whole, so you're wearing jewellery nobody can actually see, which rather defeats the point.
Next time you're looking at a pair, check the back first, not the front. A flimsy, wobbly back on a lovely looking stud tells you everything about the corners cut to get the price down.