A good pair has weight to it before anything else. Not heavy like clip on earrings that leave a dent behind your ear by eleven in the morning, but a proper drop and swing when you pick them up off the dressing table, so you know they'll move when you turn your head instead of just sitting there looking apologetic. Cheap statement earrings feel like they came out of a cracker. Good ones feel like they've got somewhere to be.
In the shop, before anything else, check the back. Butterfly backs on something with real length or weight will not hold, and you'll spend the whole day doing that subtle head tilt to stop one sliding forward. Look at the finish close up too, not at arm's length under shop lighting that flatters everything, because that's where you spot the plating that's already gone thin at the edges or the stone that's been glued in slightly crooked. I learned this the hard way with a pair of gold hoops with drops that looked brilliant on the stand and turned distinctly green behind my ears within a fortnight, which nobody warns you about. Once you've got a good pair home, they do change over the months. Metal plating wears at the point of contact first, so the bit that touches your neck will dull before the rest, and that's normal, not a fault. Keep them out of the bathroom steam, take them off before you put perfume on rather than after, and if they start looking tired, a jewellery cloth does more than you'd expect. The ones with fabric or thread elements need the most care, they fray at the exact point you grab them to put them in, so handle them by the hook, not the drop.
Fit here isn't about size, it's about weight and placement. Earrings this size pull on the earlobe, and if yours are already slightly stretched, a heavy drop will twist the hole forward over a few wears, which is uncomfortable and permanent. Try them on and move your head properly, not just a glance in the mirror, because the ones that gape away from your neck or swing into your jaw when you talk will do that every single time you wear them, not just in the shop. If you wear glasses, check the drop doesn't catch the arm, that's a specific kind of irritating nobody mentions until it's happening to you on a train.
The best ones have a sound. Not a jangle, something quieter, a small movement near your jaw that you only really notice when the room goes briefly silent and you realise you've still got your earrings on.
Once you're done here, give black earrings five minutes.