The first thing I do with a pair of white earrings is turn them over and have a proper look at the back, because the colour is either part of the material or it's paint sitting on top of the metal, and paint has a short, undignified life once it meets a coat pocket or a makeup bag. Mother of pearl, bone, shell, white enamel fired properly onto a base, these keep their colour because it goes all the way through. A thin white coating over cheap metal starts chipping at the edges within a few wears, and what you're left with looks less like jewellery and more like something that's been nibbled.
Once you've got past that, white earrings turn out to be one of the easier things to build an outfit around, which surprised me the first time I actually thought about it properly rather than just reaching for gold out of habit. They sit happily against navy, black, grey, camel, any of the colours most of us actually live in day to day, and they don't fight with patterned tops the way a bright stone can. The shades that wear best over time are the slightly off whites rather than the stark, bleached ones, an ivory pearl or a warm bone tone, because pure white earrings next to skin can look faintly clinical by ten in the morning once your face has settled into the day. Freshwater pearl is the one I trust most for longevity, it doesn't yellow the way some resins do after a summer of sun cream and sweat, and it survives being tipped out of a washbag at a bathroom sink more times than it probably should. Shell and bone hold up well too, provided the edges are smoothed properly and not left sharp enough to catch on a scarf. They come into their own from spring through to late summer, against bare arms and lighter fabrics, but a single pearl stud works just as well under a winter coat for something that reads as finished without looking like you've tried.
What they're less good at is surviving a swim, a hot shower with them still in, or six months loose in the bottom of a handbag rattling against your keys. Treat them with a little care and they'll outlast most of what you bought them to go with.
So before I buy a pair, I ask myself one thing: if I hold these under a proper light, is that white going to still be white in a year, or is it paint waiting for an excuse to come off?
Want something a little different? Check out stud earrings.