If you are holding a set in the changing room and wondering whether it is worth it over buying pieces separately, my answer depends entirely on whether the necklace and earrings actually look like they belong together or just happen to be in the same box. Some sets are designed as one thing, the pendant echoing the earring shape, the chain weight matching. Others are clearly three leftover pieces bundled together to shift stock. Hold them against your collarbone and your ear at the same time if you can, not one after the other, because that is how you will actually wear them.
Before you buy, check the clasp properly, not just that it closes but that it closes without a fight, because a stiff lobster clasp is fine in a shop under good light and a nightmare at half past six with cold hands. Look at the back of any stud or stone setting too. Cheap sets often look perfect from the front and a bit rough round the edges the moment you turn them over, glue visible, prongs uneven. Check the earring backs are a proper fit for the post, not loose, because loose backs are how you lose an earring at a bus stop and never notice until you get home.
On sizing, necklaces are the one to get right since you cannot adjust a bracelet or earring much. Go for a set with at least two clasp positions on the chain if you have any uncertainty about length, and know that a choker length sits very differently on a long neck than a short one. If a bracelet in the set feels snug in the shop, it will feel tight after a few wears once the clasp beds in slightly looser and swings around, so slightly loose is the safer side of error.
If you own none of this kind of thing, start with a simple set in one finish, gold or silver, not mixed metal, and a design you could wear with a plain neckline. It gives you the most mileage before you start building out anything more specific.
What separates a good one from a disappointing one shows up after a few months, not in the shop. Proper plating does not go patchy at the clasp or earring post where sweat and perfume sit. Stones stay put rather than working loose in the setting. A chain that is well made will not kink or tangle every time it comes out of a bag, and that is the real test, because most of us are not storing jewellery in velvet boxes, we are shoving it in a side pocket on the way out the door.
Reach for a set on the days you want to look finished without making ten small decisions, a wedding, an interview, a dinner you have no energy to overthink.
Next stop, chokers.