Chokers suit a longer neck and a bit of confidence about drawing the eye upward. If your neck is shorter, or you carry any fullness under the chin, a tight band sitting right at the base can make that area look more crowded rather than less, so it is worth trying one on properly rather than buying blind from a flat lay photo.
I am tall enough that most necklaces hang somewhere around my collarbone whether I like it or not, so a choker is one of the few pieces of jewellery that actually sits where it is meant to on me. That has made me notice when the rest of an outfit is doing the choker no favours. They come into their own for evenings, for anything with a bare shoulder, a scoop neck or an off the shoulder top, where there is a stretch of clear skin for the band to sit against. In winter they can look a bit lost under layers, and a polo neck or a cowl will simply hide the thing entirely, which feels like a waste of a nice ribbon. Festival season and summer dresses with a square or sweetheart neckline are where I reach for mine most, because there is nothing else competing for that bit of real estate.
On colour and finish, I have learned the hard way that a thin black velvet ribbon or a narrow gold chain earns its wear far more often than anything wide or heavily embellished. The velvet one I bought years ago, slightly too snug, left a faint red line on my neck by the end of an evening, which taught me to size up rather than assume one measurement fits everyone. A fine matte chain in gold or silver goes with almost anything in your jewellery box already, while a thick, high shine metal choker reads as a statement piece and needs the rest of the outfit kept deliberately plain. Velvet in black or deep colours is forgiving against most skin tones. Anything with a lot of bright stone or crystal starts to look costumey under daylight, however lovely it seemed under shop lighting.
Where it falls apart is layering greed. A choker with a long pendant necklace underneath, a polo neck, a high collared shirt or a scarf tied at the throat is simply too much happening in one small space, and your eye cannot settle on any of it. Big statement earrings alongside a wide choker have the same effect, pulling attention in two directions at once.
Worn on its own, against clear skin, it is a quietly good addition to an evening you have already half dressed for.