The first thing I check is the back band, not the cup. If I can pinch more than an inch of slack straight out of the box, it's going to be loose by week three, because bands stretch with wear, cups don't need to. I also run a finger along the inside of the underwire before I buy anything, looking for a seam that feels like it's been glued rather than sewn. A black bra hides a lot visually, which is exactly why people get lazy about fit, and exactly why I don't. Black is unforgiving about construction even though it's forgiving about everything else.
Where it falls short is in anything pale or fine. White shirts, thin cream jumpers, anything with a bit of sheen in good light, and a black bra will ghost through the fabric no matter how expensive it was. I learned that one properly on a work trip, stood under the office strip lighting looking like I'd worn a target under a silk blouse, and now I keep a nude one specifically for that. It's also not the bra for a strapless dress or anything backless, obviously, but people do try, and it never ends well. As for wear, a good black bra in a cotton and elastane mix will hold its shape for months if you're sensible with it, lasting through dozens of wears before the elastic gives up. Lace ones look lovely for about six weeks and then the scalloped edge starts to curl and go a bit grey at the friction points, usually under the arm where your bag strap sits all day. Hand washing in cool water keeps the black properly black for much longer than the machine does, and if you must machine wash, a lingerie bag and a cold cycle stop the hooks mangling everything else in there. Never the tumble dryer. The elastane gives up its stretch in heat and you're left with something that looks fine on the hanger and does nothing on the body, which is the worst kind of disappointing because you won't notice until you're already out the door.
Black is the one I reach for most of the year, honestly, because it goes under dark workwear, under denim, under most evening things without a second thought, and it doesn't show through anything navy or charcoal the way a bright colour sometimes will under thin fabric. Winter, autumn, any stretch where I'm in darker clothes daily, it's doing more hours than anything else in the drawer. Summer I swap in paler ones for linen and white cotton, but the black never properly goes away.
The mistake is buying it in whatever size you wore five years and one bra fitting ago, and assuming black will disguise the fact that it doesn't fit. It won't. It just hides the evidence while your back does all the complaining.
Next stop, lace bras.