The run up to any season of parties, weddings or work dos is when black heels stop being an afterthought and start being the thing you actually plan an outfit around. Office Christmas do in December, a wedding in a marquee in June, a leaving do on a random Tuesday, black heels are the one shoe that doesn't ask what the dress code is before it says yes.
The difference between a pair that lasts and a pair that lets you down shows up fast, usually around the third wear. Cheap man made uppers crease across the toe box within weeks and never quite recover, whereas leather or a good leather look softens and moulds to your foot instead. Check the lining too, a breathable leather or textile lining keeps your foot from sliding and sweating inside a patent shoe on a warm night. The heel itself matters more than people admit, a block or a wider stiletto with a proper metal pin inside holds its line for years, while a thin plastic covered heel wears unevenly at the tip and starts tilting you sideways within a season. Stitching should be even and close to the edge, glue lines along the sole are the tell of a shoe built to a price rather than built to last.
Looked after, a good pair earns its stripes rather than its scuffs. Suede needs a brush after every outing and a spray before its first, patent needs nothing more than a wipe and never direct heat near it, and leather benefits from a cream polish a few times a year to stop it drying out and cracking at the crease. Get heel tips replaced the moment they wear down to the metal, it costs very little and saves the sole from taking damage it won't recover from. Rotate two pairs if you can, resting a pair for a few days lets the insole and lining dry out properly and the shoe keeps its shape for longer. Where black heels genuinely let you down is anywhere with cobbles, long grass, or four hours of standing, a thin heel and an unforgiving sole will ruin an evening no matter how good they look walking in. They're also the wrong call for anything daytime and casual, black heels dressed down just look like you've got somewhere smarter to be later and haven't quite got there yet. Save them for evenings, for the kind of event with a dress code, and for the months when the rest of your wardrobe goes dark anyway, autumn into winter, when black heels stop standing out and start just fitting in.