Stand two women across a room in brown heels and you'll spot the difference before you clock anything else about the outfit. One looks like she's been wearing proper shoes her whole life. The other looks like she borrowed her nan's and is hoping nobody looks too closely at the plastic sheen catching the light.
Brown heels earn their place from September through to about April, when black feels a bit severe and everything else in your rail has gone warm and heavy. They're the ones you reach for with camel coats, with knitwear, with anything that's got a bit of russet or olive or rust running through it, because brown sits in that family and doesn't fight anything. Where they do clash is cool toned black and white, anything icy or stark, a crisp white shirt dress with sharp black accents looks like it's been dressed by two different people if you put a warm tan heel underneath it. And can we talk about the tights situation. Sheer black tights with a mid brown shoe is a combination that's never once worked, on anyone, in the history of legs. If you're wearing tights with these, go bare, nude or a warm brown that actually continues the line rather than cutting it off at the ankle like someone's drawn a border on your leg.
Check the shoe in your hands before you check it on your feet. Run a thumb across the toe and the back of the heel, because cheap brown leatherette scuffs white at the first contact with a kerb and never properly takes the colour back, while a decent one darkens slightly with wear and starts to look like it's actually yours. A good pair ages like a handbag, a bad pair ages like a bin bag left out in the rain. Keep a tin of brown polish or cream in the house, not the clear stuff, and wipe them down after a wet pavement day rather than leaving the salt marks to set in overnight.
Where they're the wrong call is anything properly formal in black and silver, or a cool grey suit where warm brown just looks like you ran out of options. Tomorrow I'd put mine with dark jeans and a cream jumper and not think about it again.