Pick one up off the rail and the good ones have a bit of swing to them before you've even got the zip done up, a kind of weight that falls away from the waist rather than clinging on for dear life. You hold it against yourself in the changing room and you can already tell, just from how the fabric drops, whether it's going to sit flat over your hips or cup every curve you were hoping to hide today. That's the whole trick of this shape. It's cut to skim rather than grip, and you can feel that honesty in the cloth before you've taken a single step.
This is the skirt that earns its spot in fairly ordinary weeks. A denim one takes you through a long stretch of spring where it's not quite warm enough for bare legs but you're sick of trousers. A midi in a heavier cotton or a wool blend carries you through autumn with boots and tights without any fuss. Linen blends are glorious in proper heat but crease if you so much as sit down for twenty minutes, so I only reach for mine on days I know I'm not getting on a bus. For everyday wear, a cotton with a touch of stretch in it behaves itself far better and doesn't need ironing after every wash, which matters more than people admit. On your ordinary days it sits happily under a jumper tucked in loosely, or with a fitted t shirt and a denim jacket thrown over, and it does the quiet work of making trainers look deliberate rather than lazy.
If you've got none of these and you're starting from nothing, go for a mid length in a mid weight cotton, somewhere around the knee or just below, in black or navy before anything patterned. It's the one that goes with a jumper in January and a plain top in June, and it won't show every crease like linen or cling like a jersey knit can on a warm day. Avoid anything too stiff at first, a structured A line in a thick twill can stand away from the body a bit too much until you know you like the shape, and a cheap polyester version will go shiny at the seat within a few wears, which nobody needs to know but you.
Give it a year of proper wear and it softens at the waistband, the hem starts to sit slightly differently from how it hung on the rail, and the whole thing moves with you rather than at you, which is honestly when it starts looking like it's actually yours.