The first thing I do with a cream skirt is hold it up to the window. Cheap cream is flat and chalky, it reads as a colour rather than a fabric, and under any kind of light it looks like a costume. Good cream has movement in it, a bit of warmth, almost a shadow of ivory or oatmeal underneath, and that's what stops it looking like a school uniform skirt that's wandered into adult life by mistake.
What separates the ones worth keeping from the ones you'll bin after two wears usually comes down to weight and lining. A skirt with no lining in a pale colour is asking for trouble, you end up either wearing it under lights like an X-ray or stuck wearing a slip every single time, which gets old fast. Check the seams too, cream shows a badly finished seam the way white shows a coffee stain, instantly and without mercy. Decent stitching, a proper hem that doesn't pucker, a zip that sits flat rather than puckering the fabric around it, these are the things that tell you someone finished the job rather than rushing it through a machine at the last possible stage. A midi in a cotton and linen mix with a bit of structure will keep its shape and drape properly against tights or bare legs, a floaty polyester one in the wrong cut can look cheap no matter what you pay for it.
It's not the right choice for everything, and I'd be lying if I pretended otherwise. Anything involving red wine, toddlers with felt tips, or a long train journey with questionable seats needs a serious risk assessment first. Cream also does nothing for you if you want to disappear into a crowd, it draws the eye, so it's a poor pick for the day you want to blend into a meeting unnoticed. Where it does work is the ordinary stuff, a cream skirt with a plain navy jumper and loafers, or a white t shirt and sandals in summer, it does more for an outfit than most people expect from something so simple, mostly because it looks deliberate without looking fussy.
In the shop, hold the fabric up to a window again, this time to check it isn't see through at the thigh, because changing room lighting lies. Check the lining extends properly rather than stopping at the knee while the skirt carries on another four inches. Run a finger along the waistband for any pulling or puckering, and check buttons or hooks are properly anchored rather than attached by what looks like one optimistic thread.
The real mistake is buying it in exactly the shade that matches nothing else you own, so it sits there unworn because nothing quite goes, and you end up wondering why you bothered.
My other suggestion would be gold skirts.