The crease across the toe is the thing nobody mentions. On a cheap pair it shows up by week three, a hard fold that never softens, because the leather is really just coated fabric pretending. On a good pair, the crease still comes, leather always moves, but it softens into the shoe rather than sitting on top of it like a scar. That's the difference a shop floor won't show you, because every loafer looks identical under lights on day one.
Before you buy, bend the sole in your hand. If it won't flex at all, your feet will be fighting it for a month. If it flexes like paper, there's nothing holding the shape and it'll collapse at the sides within a season. Check the stitching round the apron, the seam that runs over the top of the foot, because loose or uneven stitching there is usually the first thing to go. On sizing, loafers run differently to almost anything else you own, they're built to sit close at the heel and loose at the toe, so don't size up just because your toes feel snug on first try, that's often the heel grip doing its job rather than the length being wrong. Walk a proper distance in the shop, not three steps to a mirror. Watch for heel slip, which gets worse not better with wear, and for a toe box that pinches across the widest part of your foot, because loafers don't stretch the way trainers do. A full sock on a bare foot, even in summer, makes a surprising difference to how they break in. They don't get on with skinny trousers that stop short and show acres of ankle in a way that looks accidental rather than chosen, and they look wrong under anything too formal, a loafer reads relaxed even in good leather, so a sharp tailored suit can make them look like you ran out of proper shoes. They're at their best with a cropped straight leg trouser, a midi skirt with a thick sock in colder months, or bare ankle in summer, and they carry you through most of the year except genuinely wet days, when the sole gives you no grip and the leather on the cheaper ones marks the second it meets a puddle.
Tomorrow morning I'd put mine with wide leg trousers that break just above the shoe, a plain fine knit tucked in loosely, and a coat that doesn't need anything fussy under it because the shoes are already doing enough talking.