The usual mistake is buying a blazer so structured it only works standing up straight with your shoulders back, and then wondering why it lives at the back of the rail. A blazer has to survive sitting down, driving, carrying bags, bending to pick things up off the floor. If it only looks good in the mirror for the four seconds you're standing still, it's not earning its space.
Stick to navy, a mid grey or a soft camel if you want one that works with almost everything you own, because black can look severe against daytime clothes and goes slightly flat under office lighting. A check in muted tones is a nice second buy once you trust the shape, but it's a harder colour to repeat week to week without people clocking it. For fit, the shoulder seam is the bit that matters most, it should sit right at the edge of your shoulder, not droop down your arm or pull tight across the back when you bring your arms forward, which is the first thing to check and the thing shops never tell you to check. Sleeve length wants to stop around the wrist bone, and if you're between sizes, go up rather than down, a blazer that's slightly roomy through the body can be brought in by a tailor for not much money, but one that's tight across the back never relaxes with wear, it just stays tight. Watch the length too, anything that hits mid thigh can shorten your legs if you're not tall, and a cropped one can look unfinished over trousers with a low rise. A relaxed fit is the easiest starting point if you've never owned one, because it forgives a day of sitting at a desk or in a car and doesn't strain across the back when you lean forward for a bag, a tin, whatever's on the floor.
If you've got none, start with a single breasted one in navy or grey, lightly structured rather than stiff, because that's the version that goes over a plain top with jeans on a Tuesday and over a dress for something slightly dressier without looking like it's trying. It sits well over a roll neck in fast moving autumn weather, works thrown over bare arms in spring, and struggles the moment real heat arrives, most blazers are wasted dead weight in a heatwave, so don't expect to reach for one in July. Pair it with straight leg trousers, a plain tee, a midi skirt, it's not fussy about what's underneath as long as the shoulders are doing their job.
What it won't do is replace a proper coat once the weather turns properly cold, it's a layer for mild days and indoor warmth, nothing more.