The thing that catches people out with summer party outfits is the lighting test nobody does before they buy. A dress that looks rich and expensive under shop spotlights can turn see through, or just plain flat, the second you step into daylight or a garden marquee at seven in the evening. I have stood in a garden in a dress I thought was opaque, holding a glass of something cold, acutely aware that anyone behind me could tell exactly what colour my underwear was. And yet I still buy into this category every year, because nothing else in my own wardrobe gives me that lift of actually looking forward to getting dressed, rather than just getting dressed.
Colour wise, the ones that earn repeat wear are usually not the loudest ones on the rail. A deep berry, a warm terracotta, a proper block black with some shine to it, these go further than the acid brights that photograph well for ten minutes and then feel wrong by the time you are queueing for a drink. Metallics in a soft gold or pewter rather than anything too silver and disco ball tend to sit better against most skin tones too. Where the good ones separate from the disappointing ones is in the fabric and the finish, not the print. A proper weight of satin that drapes rather than clings in the wrong places, a lining that actually exists and is cut to the same shape as the dress, a zip that sits flat instead of gaping at the small of your back after one sit down dinner. Sequins should be stitched in rows that overlap, not glued, because glued ones shed all over a taxi seat and you will be finding them in your hallway at Christmas.
Where it falls apart is in the pairing, not the piece itself. A heavily embellished top does not need a busy bag or shoes with their own hardware shouting for attention, pick one feature and let the rest go quiet. Chunky knit cardigans and anything obviously winter weight undo the whole effort the moment it gets draped over bare shoulders for warmth, so if you know you run cold, sort that out with something lighter before the night rather than after. And strong, structured tailoring worn underneath a floaty party piece almost always looks like two outfits had an argument and both lost.
Before I put anything from this rail in my basket now, I ask myself one thing: would I still want to be wearing this three hours in, after the second drink, once I have forgotten I am wearing it at all?