I kept corset tops out of my life for years, convinced they only worked on someone with a stylist and a reason to be photographed. A work do I almost cancelled on changed that, because the only clean top I had left was one of these, and it turned out to be the most comfortable thing I wore all night.
They are not for every day, and I think that is the bit people skip past. A corset top with proper boning digs in when you sit for long stretches, so it is a poor match for a desk job or a train journey with no breaks, and in real heat the structured ones turn into a sweatbox by the second hour. They do their best work for a few hours at a time, somewhere you are mostly standing or moving about, and they suit fitted trousers or a straight skirt far more than anything already full at the waist, because two shaped pieces together just cancel each other out. In deep winter they want a jacket over the top, since most are sleeveless or strapless and not built to be the whole outfit once the temperature drops.
The difference between one that earns its spot and one that ends up at the back of a drawer is almost entirely in the inside, not the outside. Cheap ones use thin plastic boning that bends out of shape after a few wears and starts to pop visibly against thin fabric. A better one has sturdier boning sewn into actual channels, not just glued or stitched flat, and a lining heavy enough that the seams and any zip don't print through. Check the busk or zip at the front or back, it should sit flush and not pull or gape when you breathe normally rather than holding your breath for the mirror. Grommets and lacing, if there are any, should be metal and properly set, not the kind that start to rust after one hand wash.
Fit is where I went wrong the first time, buying a size down because the boning looked rigid enough to force everything into place, which just gave me a red line across my ribs by nine o'clock. Go with your actual measurement, not what you think the structure will do for you, and pay attention to where the top of the boning sits against your bust, since that is the spot most likely to dig or gap depending on your shape. Sit down in it before you decide, properly sit, because standing in front of a mirror tells you almost nothing about how it behaves an hour in.
The first thing worth checking, before fabric or colour, is whether the boning channels are stitched flat and finished, not just glued.
While you're here, don't skip green tops.