My first peplum top came from a market stall, pale blue, with a flounce that stuck out from my waist like a lampshade. It taught me that the shape only works if the fabric underneath it has some structure, because mine was so thin and floppy that the peplum just folded in on itself by lunchtime and sat there looking defeated rather than flattering.
Getting the fit right is mostly about where the seam sits, not the size on the label. You want that join, the point where the fitted bit meets the flare, to land at the narrowest part of your waist or just above it, because if it sits too low it adds width exactly where you don't need it, and if it sits too high it can look like you're wearing two separate garments that got stuck together by accident. Try it sitting down as well as standing, since a peplum that behaves beautifully standing still can ride up and bunch when you sit, especially if the fabric is stiff. Check the fitted part across the bust and shoulders too, because that's the part doing the actual work of shaping you, and if that's loose the peplum has nothing to flare out from, it just hangs. A lot of women size up for comfort around the middle and then wonder why the whole thing looks shapeless, when really the fix is a size that fits close through the body and lets the peplum do its job from a proper starting point.
Where it falls short is anywhere you need to move freely or sit for long stretches without thinking about it. Under a blazer, that flare gets trapped and creases oddly, and anything involving a lot of bending, carrying boxes, playing with small children on the floor, gets awkward fast because the hem catches. It's also not kind to very textured or heavy fabrics, since a stiff tweed peplum can look like armour rather than shape. And if your proportions are already quite curved through the hip, a wide flared peplum can add bulk rather than definition, in which case a shorter, tighter flounce does far more for you than a dramatic one.
The better ones, with a bit of cotton or a touch of structure woven in, hold their shape wash after wash and the peplum keeps its spring rather than going limp. Cheaper, thinner versions soften with every wash until the flare just droops, so hand washing or a gentle cycle, folded rather than hung so the seam doesn't stretch, keeps it looking like it did on day one for far longer.
This suits anyone who wants a defined waist without a fitted dress, and wants it in something they can wear with trousers on a normal Tuesday.
Take a look at mesh tops before you decide.