The first winter skirt I owned was a thin black jersey thing from a budget shop, bought for a tenner because I needed "something smart" for a work do with about two days' notice. It taught me that a skirt with no structure and no lining is basically a long jumper that stops at the knee, and that cold knees make you walk differently, quicker, crosser, less inclined to enjoy wherever you're going. After that I started actually thinking about what a skirt needed to do before December got anywhere near it.
If you've got none in the rotation right now, start with something in a heavier fabric, a wool mix or a thick cord, in a length that sits at or just below the knee, because that's the one that works with boots, tights and a jumper without any negotiation. A-line is more forgiving than pencil if you're not sure yet, it skims rather than clings and it survives sitting down on a bus without riding up into something embarrassing. Skip anything pleated and flimsy as a first buy, it photographs nicely on a hanger and does nothing for you at a bus stop in February. Pair it with thick tights or leggings underneath on the proper cold days, a jumper tucked in just at the front rather than all the way round, and boots with a sole that can handle actual pavement, not just a dry shop floor. A wool or wool mix skirt will need a cold hand wash or a gentle machine cycle and a flat dry, never a hot tumble, because that's how a decent skirt turns into something that fits your daughter in three years and nobody else.
Fit is where these go wrong twice as often as jeans, in my experience. The waistband is the first thing to check, sitting on your actual waist rather than halfway down your hip, because a skirt that slides down all day under a jumper will have you hoiking it up on every street corner, which is not a good look and not a comfortable one either. Check it sitting down as well as standing, a skirt that's fine standing in the shop can pull tight across the thighs the second you sit on a train, and check the hem doesn't flip up when you walk, which happens more with A-line cuts in slippery fabrics than anyone warns you about. Wool mixes ease slightly with wear, so if it's snug on day one through the hips, that's usually fine, but if it's tight sitting down from the start, it won't magically loosen enough to matter.
Buy the size that sits comfortably at the waist when you're seated, not just standing still in front of the mirror.
We've also got cosy winter outfits, if that's more your thing.