This past Thursday morning, I sprint into the elevator at my apartment building, nearly missing it. My neighbor slips in behind me. It’s Sarah from the fourth floor, we know each other well enough to do those embarrassing how-are-you neighborly-small-talk chats maybe once a month.
She’s wearing wide-leg cargo pants, a cropped tank top, fraying Uggs that cost more than my monthly T pass, and so many silver rings that the elevator probably alarms. She’s basically the Human Trophy Wall of Optics Co., channeling major cool-girl vibes that I will never, ever attain without looking like a try-hard. It’s hot out and we’re both complaining about how disgusting the humidity is, totally mundane elevator chatter.
When I see Sarah the following morning, it hits me how drastically our outfits differ. She greets me from inside the elevator wearing a prairie-inspired midi dress with puff sleeves and ballet flats, plus an actual ribbon tied in her hair.
I’m half expecting her to whip out a butter churn instead of a MetroCard. “I know we talked about the weather yesterday, but I thought that today we could discuss your radical outfit transformation.” I can’t resist teasing her.
She laughs. “Oh this? Yesterday was alt-day. I’m feeling cute as a coquette today.
Maybe tomorrow I’ll go full coastal grandma because I’m meeting my real grandmother for lunch and she loves when I dress like her.” Side note: this is not Sarah the fashion experimenter. Sarah from 4B had, until fairly recently, a consistent rotation of Everlane tees and white sneakers. The type of blandly safe wardrobe I secretly admired because at least she never had to think about what she was going to wear.
Now she’s rocking different fully realized aesthetics every day of the week. I’ve thought about this elevator interaction a lot over the past week because something feels symbolic to me about bumping into Sarah like that. We all seem to be experiencing some sort of collective identity crisis through the lens of fashion.
Or is having a signature style just… over? Replaced by a constantly shifting mood/personality-based wardrobe we would’ve ridiculed ten years ago. “I don’t feel like I even have a look anymore,” my friend Kate texted me recently. Kate is someone who spent her whole twenties curating an extremely specific wardrobe: nothing but black, white, and camel garments shaped into incredibly architectural silhouettes.
I’d always been a little intimidated by how polished and consistent she always looked. “Some days I feel like running an art gallery in Soho. Other days I feel like teaching ceramics in Cloud Valley, Iowa. Who knows, it changes based on my mood.” When I asked Kate if this made getting dressed feel more difficult, she scoffed. “It’s the opposite.
I don’t try to define my identity through what I’m wearing anymore. I literally just think about what mood I want to embrace that day.” A lot of research goes into any story I write, but I truly found myself understanding this trend more by talking to people about their everyday wardrobes than anything else. So when I sat down with Dr.
Mina Chen, a Parsons faculty member who specializes in fashion psychology, I already had a good sense of what she would confirm: we have totally lost our collective shit. “Our generation is seeing something called aesthetic fragmentation,” Dr. Chen told me. “In the past, people created more unified style identities because their exposure to fashion was through fewer, large-scale touchpoints like magazines or movies. Today’s generation is influenced by thousands of small micro-trends and communities via Instagram and TikTok, so they have this extremely eclectic reserve of aesthetics to dip into each day.” Think about it: online shopping data agrees that we’re maxing out our style credit card.
StyleScan just released data showing that the average person bought across six aesthetic categories last year, versus three or four categories 10 years ago. Edit-leading fashion brands are telling us behind the scenes that full outfits are so last season – now buyers at all major retailers want “clusters” of clothing that touch on a variety of looks (they literally asked me not to name them because I’d undoubtedly massacre their name). We’re basically Kardashians assembling our “fits” from scratch each day.
Plus, the concept of buying and wearing one vibe on repeat is very strategically buried on TikTok, the #1 influencer of how we get dressed today. If you spend any amount of time scrolling these days, you’ve definitely seen those “showing you all my different aesthetics for different days!” videos. I watched hours of content like this last week while trying to understand the phenomenon.
The hashtag #aesthetichopping has been viewed nearly HALF A BILLION TIMES. “I have different inspiration Pinterest boards for all my favorite aesthetics,” said Lily, a 24-year-old with 350k followers on the app whom I discovered while scrolling. “Whenever I get dressed, I ask myself how I’m feeling that day and which inspiration board I feel most aligned with. If I knew y’all were watching, I would’ve dressed totally different yesterday. I went with vintage vibe day, but today I’m grunge.” Gen Z might be hitting you with a new aesthetic every hour, but I’ve been talking to people of all ages about this, and it is pretty universal.
It’s older generations, too. “My parents now have multiple jewelry styles they rotate through each week,” my colleague Amanda texted me. “They send me photos throughout the day like “Issa Gigi Hadid today’ and “Embodying minimalist Swedish farmhouse vibes.” My parents raised me wearing the same dang pearls every day for over 30 years.” Logistically, it’s also easier than ever to hop between trends. Luxury rental? Check.
Pinterest board scrapicing? Check. Wish-sized clothing options that’ll allow you to cheaply slurp up every trend?
You Might Also Like
DOUBLE CHECK. “The ability to easily switch between aesthetics hasn’t ever been easier,” said Jordan Kim, retail analyst at TN Solution when I reached out for his thoughts. “With the rise of rental platforms, thrifting apps, and deeply discounted fast fashion, shoppers can now engage with any style at any price point. Investing in a few staple pieces that fit into your personal style feels intimidating when you can Seamlessly rotate your entire aesthetic for cheaper than buying one designer bag.” Not only are customers confusing brands with how they shop (literally one day VETements, next day Chanel???) but now they want that unpredictable variety within stores too. “A month doesn’t go by where we aren’t brainstorming how to give our customers more ‘editorial’ options,” one brand founder whose brand falls into this bucket told me on the condition of anonymity. Brands large and small are shaking in their boots. “We used to have shop by aesthetic filters on our website,” the same retailer told me. “Now we’re thinking about how to implement a picker into the shopping cart so you can guarantee your tank top and sweatpants come from different aesthetics.” Sure, back in the day somebody may have spent $400 on a Rachel Comey dress.

Now? They can grab multiple “looks” for that same price on Shein. But beneath all this industry-talk and economic-talk and fluidity-talk what I really want to understand is why?
We are so into aesthetics – what does that say about us as people? “When we talk about ‘personal style,’ we’re typically referring to a very specific manifestation: a consistent style that represents who you are,” Dr. Chen told me when I asked her about the psychology of it all. “An inconsistent, ever-changing rotation of styles doesn’t allow you to express your identity in the same way. Nowadays, we see identity as fluid, so why should our style be held to the same standard?” That deep-rooted idea of having one look, of being somehow “yourself” when you wear a little black dress or Supreme merch has been destabilized over the past decade.
From how we perceive gender to our relationship with careers, the longstanding cultural expectation to “pick something and stick with it” is being challenged left and right. Exploration of identity through clothing is just one extremely public avenue this flight takes. “I used to feel like I needed to have one uniform, tried-and-true ‘look,’” Kate told me when I asked her about it. “But who cares? Some days I feel badass in wide-leg pants and other days I want to die but look cute doing it.
I’m not the same person every day, why should my wardrobe be?” There is undeniable empowerment in being able to express yourself however you’re feeling that day. I know I put so much pressure on myself growing up to have some sort of look, to unlock that coveted effortless-chic buzzphrasedemic girl vibe that everyone teases but nobody can actually define. Maybe we’re now moving into an era where you don’t have to sacrifice all mystery to have a clear sense of style.
Where you can wake up on Monday and decide you’re GiGi, and by Wednesday you are Rihanna. But not everybody is celebrating this shift. There are people in the industry who see these attitudes as incredibly destructive. “This is not fashion freedom.
This is a lack of style literacy,” Diane, who’s been a stylist in NYC for over three decades told me when I asked for some negative opinion. “Style should take years to develop, it’s a collaboration between you and what you feel looks best on you. There’s no discovery if you’re chopping from one aesthetic to the next.” Not to mention, where does this Leave our environment? Nobody’s debate piece is going to dive deep enough into the complexity of sustainability but hear me out on this – yes, renting, yes, thrifting.
But at a certain point, how many outfits can you hop through before you’ve emptied Whole Foods landfill of viable clothing options? Mourning the loss of personal style is a privilege when so many people can’t afford to develop one. “I think people are using mood dressing as an excuse to buy more,” Maria Torres, founder of Wardrobe Crisis UK told me. “You can totally build a wardrobe that allows you to jump between mood without constantly consuming new things. But I fear we’re using ‘trying new aesthetics’ as a excuse to buy.” In anything I write, there’s almost always one side that I lean closer to than the other.
With this story, I think we fall somewhere in the middle. Yes, we are embracing a wider array of styles that we feel fit our mood than any generation before us. But I think we’ve always done this to an extent. “The coolest dressed people have always had range,” our secret retail buyer said. “Think Rihanna.
Think David Bowie. Sure, they may have operated within a particular fashion era, but they would never be accused of looking ‘basic.’ I think we all have the ability to be as aesthetically versatile as they are. We just actually are.” I have definitely found myself thinking about what I’m wearing more as anything fits into my mood that day.
Sure, I still have staples that I know look good on me and that I’ll reach for season after season.
But if I wake up feeling ridiculous, I’ll wear the stupidest thing knowing that I can always tone it down tomorrow. A week ago I wore an all black-minimalism-inspired outfit to an art opening, a bright flowy dress when I met friends for drinks, and oversized “Netflix pants” to the office.
God forbid I leave my house in the same general “style” twice in one week. I bumped into Sarah from the elevator a few days later, too. She was wearing skinny jeans, a Sports Illustrated bikini top, and running shoes.
Prepping for a day at the beach? “Cool chic today?” I asked. She laughed. “ Nahhh I’m actually just going to Trader Joes.” Maybe you love the outfit you put on today. Maybe you didn’t.
Maybe you wake up and think, I feel like a dick today so I’m wearing a Dickies complete with baggy camo pants and the barrel-style stove top heater you stole from your dad. Either way, the point is you get to do that. We live in an interesting time.
More style tips
6 October 2026Faux Leather Jackets Get A Bad Reputation Im Not Sure They DeserveMy sister came to visit last spring, saw a faux leather jacket hanging on the back...
6 October 2026My Linen Pants Came Out Of The Wash A Different Size Than I RememberedI spent a solid fifteen years telling anyone who'd listen that linen doesn't shrink, not really,...
6 October 2026Brown Or Black Leather Jacket Turned Into A Longer Decision Than It Had Any Right To BeMy sister called me on a Tuesday, which is not a day she calls, to ask...
