A black belt suits almost everyone, which sounds like a cop out but it's true. Thin waists, no waist, the lot, there's a width and a buckle out there that works. The only person I'd tell to think twice is anyone buying one purely to "finish an outfit" without checking it sits right on their actual trousers, because a belt that gapes or digs in does the opposite of finishing anything.
What it doesn't want is a fight with another piece of black hardware. A black belt with gold buckle next to silver jewellery looks like you got dressed in two different rooms at two different times. Same goes for texture, a smooth patent belt over a nubbly tweed skirt never quite settles, it just sits there looking like an accessory rather than part of the outfit. Keep the metal matching whatever else is on you, rings, watch, bag clasp, and keep the finish of the leather roughly in the same family as what it's going over. Matte with matte, shine with shine.
This is the belt that works hardest in the colder months, honestly, because it's doing a job over coats, over jumpers tucked into high waisted trousers, pulling a shapeless jumper dress in at the middle so it isn't just a sack. Come summer it still earns a spot over linen and over dresses that need cinching, but it's at its best from fairly early autumn through to the end of winter, when you're layering and need something to stop three items of clothing looking like one big beige cloud. For occasions, it's quietly brilliant for work, for dinners, for anything where you want to look like you tried without looking like you tried too hard.
Before you buy, check where the holes actually sit, because I've bought one that looked perfect on the hanger and the smallest hole still left two inches of flap hanging down my thigh like a little tail. Check the buckle for weight, a flimsy one will twist round to the side within a week and stay there. And check the backing, some are leather all the way through, some are leather stuck onto something stiffer that cracks at the fold point after a few months of bending in and out of loops. Bend it in the shop before you commit, if it's already creasing oddly there, it'll only get worse.
Get the width right for the loops you actually own and you'll reach for it more than you think. Mine's on its third winter and it's still the first thing I pick up.