Does a wide belt actually do anything, or is it just a thick strip of leather sitting on top of a dress pretending to be useful? It does do something, it gives you a waist when the garment itself has given up on the idea, and it changes the proportion of a shapeless thing in about four seconds. That's the honest appeal. It's a shortcut, not a trick.
Before you buy one, check what's actually holding it together. A lot of the cheaper ones have a stiff cardboard or plastic core wrapped in leather or faux leather, and that core is what decides whether the belt sits flat or slowly curls at the edges after a few wears, so bend it in the shop, right there, fold it back on itself a bit. If it creases sharply and stays creased, that's what it'll do on you by week three. Look at the buckle too, a wide belt lives or dies by whether the buckle closes properly without digging in, and whether there's enough adjustment in the holes for it to sit where you actually want it rather than where the last hole happens to land. Elasticated wide belts solve the sizing problem but they're softer and less structured, so they do a gentler version of the same job, more gentle wobble than firm line.
Where it stops working is anywhere you need to sit for a long stretch, on a hard chair, in a car, through a long dinner. A rigid wide belt across the ribs or waist gets uncomfortable fast, and I've spent entire evenings surreptitiously loosening mine under a table like I was defusing something. It's also the wrong choice over anything with its own fitted waist seam already doing the work, two waistlines competing just reads as fussy, not deliberate. And it's not kind to very soft, drapey fabrics, a wide stiff belt clamped over silky jersey tends to bunch the fabric above and below it rather than sitting smoothly, so you get folds in places you didn't plan for.
It clashes with anything that already has a strong horizontal detail at the same height, a contrast waistband, a peplum, a big seam, because then you've got two statements arguing in the same four inches of torso, and your eye doesn't know which one to believe. It also fights a high waisted trouser the same way, two waist markers stacked close together just look like a mistake rather than a style choice. Next time you're looking at one, check the inside of the buckle hinge and bend the whole thing in half before anything else.
Take a look at wide leg jumpsuits before you decide.