A large bag suits anyone who carries a proper life around with them, not just a phone and a card. Commuters, mums doing school pickup and three other jobs, anyone who hates the indignity of cramming a laptop into something it doesn't fit. Think twice if you're petite or already carry weight through your shoulders, because a big bag loaded up can pull you sideways without you noticing until your back complains later. Think twice too if you tend to lose things in the bottom of a bag the size of a small suitcase, since the more room you have, the more you'll bury your keys.
It doesn't sit well with anything delicate or tailored, a neat coat and a sharp shoulder line look thrown off balance under something slouchy and oversized, and a big soft bag on top of a big soft coat just reads as one shapeless mass from across the street. Where the good ones separate from the disappointing ones is almost entirely in what holds them up. Pick it up empty and see if it stands on its own or collapses into a puddle, because a bag with no structure will sag the second you put a water bottle in it and never recover its shape. Run your hand along the strap, a strap that's going to carry real weight needs to be wide enough, or doubled stitched, or it will dig a groove into your shoulder within a month. Check the hardware, the zip pull and the clasps, give them a proper tug rather than a polite one, because cheap metal shows itself immediately with a stiff zip or a clasp that doesn't click shut properly. Look at the lining too, a bag this size collects pens and lip balms and loose coins at the bottom, and a flimsy lining will have holes within a season while a decent one shrugs it off. Before you buy, open every pocket, check the seams where the strap meets the body since that's where the weight pulls and where cheap glue gives up first, and hold it against your side to see where it actually sits, because a bag that looks lovely on a mannequin can hit at an odd hip height on you and throw your whole outline off.
Given time, a well made large bag softens in a way that suits it, the leather or the sturdy canvas relaxing into creases that look earned rather than tired, the corners rounding slightly, the base taking a gentle, settled shape from everything it's carried. A badly made one just looks worn out in the same time, sagging in the wrong places, the hardware dulling unevenly. The good version ages like it's been doing a job. The bad one just looks like it gave up.