The first thing I do with any top handle bag is pick it up by the handle alone and let it hang for a few seconds, no shoulder strap, no second hand steadying it. If the handle twists or the stitching at the base feels like it's taking the strain rather than sharing it with the body of the bag, I put it straight back down. A cheap one creaks a bit under weight, almost apologetically. A good one just sits, solid, like it's been carrying things for years already.
Where this shape falls short is obvious once you've lived with one for a week. It is not built for days when you need both hands free, for the school run with a toddler attached to one arm, or for carrying a laptop and a change of shoes and a water bottle without the whole thing listing to one side. Mine goes nowhere near the supermarket. It is a bag for moving through the world holding one thing elegantly, not for hauling your life around in it, and if you try to make it do both jobs you will end up with a sore wrist and a bag that stretches out of shape at the join faster than it should.
Getting the size right comes down to the drop of the handle more than anything else. Hold it in the crook of your elbow, not just your hand, because that's where it actually lives during a normal day. Too short and it won't go over a coat sleeve in winter, which I learned the hard way standing in a doorway wrestling with mine while someone held a lift for me. Too long and it swings and knocks against your hip with every step. A lot of the better ones now come with a thin cross body strap tucked into the lining for exactly this reason, which seems sensible rather than decorative, and worth checking for before you buy.
In the shop, I check the inside lining for loose threads, the base for feet or studs that stop it sitting on a wet pavement, and the hardware for weight, light clasps and rings tend to be the first thing to go. Press the handle attachment points with a thumb. Any give there now is a snapped handle in eighteen months. This is a bag for someone who wants one beautiful object to carry on a day that doesn't involve much carrying at all, and is happy to own a separate, less precious bag for the days that do.