If you're the sort who tips your whole bag out on a bus looking for your oyster card, buy the zip one. Not the one with the flap and the magnetic popper that looks lovely for the first three weeks then gapes open every time you sit down. The zip is the boring, sensible choice, and that's exactly the point.
Where it comes unstuck is when you pile too much onto it. A zip bag with its own chunky hardware and a big branded pull does not want a scarf tied to the handle, or a keyring the size of a fist clipped on for good measure, it starts to look like you're wearing three accessories arguing with each other rather than one that's finished the job. Keep it plain and let the zip be the detail. What tells you a good one from a disappointing one is almost always in the metal and the stitching, not the leather. Run the zip up and down in the shop, properly, more than once. A good one glides, a cheap one catches on the lining about halfway and you'll be fighting it on a cold platform within a month. Look at where the zip meets the seam too, if the fabric is already puckering on the rail, that's not going to improve with wear, that's the weak point you'll be looking at every day from here on. A bag that's been thrown in and out of a bigger tote for a whole winter will tell you everything, scuffed corners are fine, a zip pull that's come away from its tab is not.
Where it genuinely isn't the right choice is anywhere you need your hands free in a hurry, a zip bag is never going to beat a snap closure for fishing your phone out one handed while you're also holding a coffee and a toddler's hand, I've dropped a phone on a platform doing exactly that and sworn, internally, never out loud. It's also not the one for evening wear that wants to look delicate, a zip across the top of a small bag can look a bit like a lunchbox if the proportions are wrong. If you've got none at all, start with a mid sized cross body in a single plain colour, one zip, no extra pockets or straps dangling off it, because that's the version that goes with everything and shows the least wear when it's inevitably been sat on the floor of a car more times than you'd admit.
If the zip ever starts sticking, rub a bit of lip balm or candle wax along the teeth rather than yanking it, it works every time and costs nothing.