Knee high boots suit anyone who wants one pair of shoes to sort out a whole season of dressing without much thought, which is most of us by about October. If you have narrow calves and wide feet, or the other way round, think twice before buying blind online, because fit is the whole story with these and a boot that looks right in a photo can still be useless on your actual leg.
I wear mine with everything from straight jeans tucked in to a midi skirt and thick tights, and that's really the test of a good pair, that they don't ask you to dress around them. A plain knee high works under a coat, under a dress, with a jumper that's slightly too long, it just quietly solves the bottom half of an outfit. Where a cheap pair falls apart is usually the shaft, it's thin, it creases oddly at the ankle and never sits flat against your leg, whereas a proper one has enough structure in the leather or a good quality synthetic that it holds its shape even when it's not on your foot. Have a feel of the inside too, a lining that's soft and continues right down into the foot rather than stopping halfway tells you a lot, as does the weight of the zip pull and whether it glides or catches. Stitching round the sole should be even, not glued looking, and the heel should feel solid when you press it with your thumb, not hollow.
If you're starting from nothing, go for a low block heel in black leather or a good leather look, nothing pointed, nothing too high, because that's the pair that gets worn on actual days rather than kept for best. A rounder toe and a heel under five centimetres means you can walk properly in them, stand at a bus stop, do stairs, and that matters more than how dramatic they look standing still. Try them sitting down as well as standing, since a boot that's fine upright can dig in behind the knee the second you bend your leg, and that's not something you notice until you've been sat in a meeting for an hour wincing.
Next time you're trying a pair on, check how the top of the boot behaves when you sit down properly, knees bent, not just a polite little curtsey in the shop mirror.
While you're here, don't skip over the knee boots.