If you are standing there holding three almost identical pairs of jeans wondering why this is so hard, the answer is that jeans are never really the decision. The outfit is. A good pair on its own just sits there, it is the top, the shoe and what you throw over it that decides whether you look like you have made an effort or like you grabbed the nearest thing off the chair.
If you own nothing to build from, start with a straight leg in a mid blue wash, not too light, not too dark, with a bit of stretch in the denim so it moves with you rather than against you. That one wash works under more things than black does, and it does not read as trying too hard the way distressed or coloured denim can. Once that is sorted, a relaxed or slightly wide leg in the same sort of wash is the next buy, because it changes the whole shape of an outfit without you having to think about anything else.
For most ordinary weeks, this combination earns its place on the school run, the supermarket, a lunch with a friend you have not seen in months, a Sunday where you still want to look like a person. Lean into layers from early autumn through to spring, a jumper, a shirt worn open, a jacket with a bit of structure, and in summer it is really about the top doing less and the jeans doing more, a plain tee, sandals, nothing fussy.
Good denim ages well if you treat it with a bit of suspicion rather than affection. Wash it less than feels right, inside out, on a cool cycle, and skip the tumble dryer unless you enjoy buying the same jeans twice because they shrank two inches. Over months a decent pair softens at the knee and fades gently at the thigh where your hand rests or your bag sits, which looks better than it sounds. Cheap stretch denim tends to bag out at the knee after a few wears and never quite recovers, so if you can feel the fabric has no real weight to it in the shop, that is worth noticing before you pay for it.
For pairing, keep it simple rather than clever. A plain tee or fine knit jumper, a jacket with some structure to balance the softness of the denim, trainers that are clean rather than battered, or boots when the weather turns. Jewellery and a good bag do more lifting in a jeans outfit than people expect, because the jeans are deliberately quiet.
If you are only choosing one wash to begin with, make it a proper mid blue. It goes under nearly everything you already own and never looks like it is trying to make a point.
Still browsing? Have a look at casual summer outfits.