I bought my first pair purely because a low rise pair had just let me down at a barbecue, sitting down on a bench with my lower back on full display, and someone's toddler pointed at it. The high rise pair I replaced them with, plain and dark and nothing special on the hanger, went on and suddenly my shirt stayed tucked, my stomach had somewhere to sit, and I didn't spend the afternoon hoiking anything up. That was the moment. Not glamorous, just relief.
Mine have been worn weekly for about two years now and they've softened in exactly the places you'd want, behind the knee, across the front of the thigh, while keeping their shape everywhere else, which tells me the denim had enough weight in it to start with. Cheap stretch denim does the opposite, it goes baggy at the knee within a month and never quite recovers, so by the third wash you're tugging at fabric that's given up. I wash mine inside out on a cold cycle and hang them rather than tumble dry, because heat is what kills the stretch and turns a good pair into something that bags at the back within a season. Twist to dry if you're desperate, never wring.
The difference between a pair that lasts and one that disappoints is mostly in your hands before you've even tried them on. Good denim has a bit of weight to it, a slight stiffness that eases rather than a floppiness that was never going to hold shape. The waistband is the tell, it should sit flat and solid, not roll or dig, and the stitching round it should be even, not wandering. Check the zip pull and button for any looseness, because that's the first thing to go and the most annoying thing to live without. Run a hand down the inside seam too, if it's rough and scratchy against your fingers it'll be rough and scratchy against your skin by hour six.
If you've got none of these, start with a straight leg in a mid to dark wash, no fading, no distressing, nothing trend led. It goes under jumpers in winter, under shirts in summer, and it won't look dated in three years the way a very specific wash or cut sometimes does. Skinny is lovely if that's your shape preference but it shows up every fit mistake, so straight is the forgiving place to begin.
Try them sitting down before you buy, not just standing at the mirror, because that's where a bad rise reveals itself.
Before you go, have a quick look at recycled jeans.