Hold it up to the light before you even think about buying it. A cheap charm necklace looks fine under shop lighting and goes dull and tinny the second you step outside, and you'll know within a week whether the charms are going to tarnish at the edges or stay put. If it feels light as nothing in your hand, that's not always a bad sign, but if it feels like nothing and looks like something, be suspicious.
This is a piece for the in between days, not the big event. It suits a Tuesday where you want to feel like you made an effort without anyone being able to say what the effort was, and it comes into its own from autumn through to the start of summer, when you're layering over jumpers and under coats and the charms sit against wool instead of bare skin, which is honestly where they look best. If you've nothing like it yet, start plain. One chain, two or three charms at most, nothing shaped like an actual object if you can help it, a disc, a bar, a simple shape you won't tire of explaining. The novelty ones, the little shoes and teapots, are lovely as a second or third piece once you know you actually wear this kind of thing, not as your first.
It sits well with plain necklines, with a shirt open one button more than you'd planned, with anything where the collarbone is doing some of the talking. Layer it under a second finer chain and it looks deliberate rather than cluttered, so long as the two don't tangle, which they will if you let them touch for more than a day without checking. It does not get on with busy prints, big florals, anything with its own going on at the neck, because the charms just disappear into the noise and you've spent money on something nobody can see. It also clashes with itself, oddly, if you load on too many charms of different metals and finishes, gold charm next to silver charm next to something rose toned looks like you emptied a drawer rather than chose an outfit.
The good ones hold their colour for years. The bad ones go a strange brassy green within a season, usually right at the point where a charm sits against your skin, which is its own quiet verdict on quality. Keep it away from perfume and let it dry properly before you put it back in its box.
Keep going with name necklaces.