The moment it clicked was a plain gold initial on a fine chain, worn under a shirt collar at a christening, visible only when I leaned forward to sign the register. Subtle, not sentimental, and I bought the same one within the week.
Before you buy, look closely at how the letter is attached rather than just how it's photographed. A soldered loop sits flat and stays facing forward; a letter strung directly onto the chain like a bead will spin round to show its back half the time, which is a small, constant irritation once you notice it. Check the thickness of the chain too, because a letter with any weight to it, especially a heavier serif font, will drag a very fine chain out of shape over months and leave it sitting crooked rather than centred. Plating matters more than it sounds like it should: solid gold or silver will survive a shower and a swim, gold plated will wear thin at the point the clasp sits, usually within a year of daily wear, faster if you're the sort who forgets to take jewellery off in the bath. I wasn't, and then I was.
If you're starting with none, go for your own initial in a plain sans serif block letter rather than a script one, on a chain around sixteen to eighteen inches. The block letter stays legible at any size, where script can blur into illegible squiggle once it's smaller than about a centimetre, and it reads as a proper piece of jewellery rather than a party favour. On length, sixteen inches sits at the base of the throat on most necks and sixteen to eighteen is the safer bet if you've a longer neck or broader shoulders, which otherwise pulls a shorter chain up higher than you'd want, sitting almost under the chin rather than resting on the collarbone. Eighteen to twenty gives you room to layer it under a second necklace later without the letter getting lost in the mix. Watch the clasp as well; a lobster clasp under six millimetres is genuinely hard to manage one handed, and you will end up asking someone to help you put it on more often than feels dignified.
If in doubt, order a size up in chain length rather than down, since a necklace sitting too high is far more noticeable than one sitting half an inch lower than planned.