There's a particular stretch of the year, somewhere around the point when the clocks change and every event invite that lands still says "come as you are" even though it's three degrees out, when flats become the only shoes I can be bothered to argue with myself about. Boots feel heavy by mid-afternoon, trainers feel wrong under a dress, and heels are a conversation I'm not having on a Tuesday. A good flat solves the whole thing before I've even left the house.
They're not right for everything, and I've learned that the hard way, usually on a wet pavement outside a venue with no grip left on the sole. Thin leather or faux leather flats with a flat, smooth bottom turn into ice skates the second there's rain or a bit of spilled drink on a dancefloor, so anything with an actual night of standing and moving ahead of it needs a flat with some texture underfoot, not just a pretty shape. They also do nothing for your calves if you're stood at a bar for three hours, no arch support means no support, full stop, so a long day on your feet, a work conference, a full day of sightseeing, will have you regretting them by four o'clock no matter how soft they looked in the box. Over months they soften at the toe and crease across the top in a way that can look lived in and nice, or can look tired, depending entirely on whether you've kept them clean and let them dry properly instead of shoving them damp into a bag after a festival field or a soggy school run. A bit of polish or cream every few weeks on leather ones keeps that crease looking like character rather than neglect, and letting them air out rather than drying on a radiator saves the shape at the heel.
Fit wise, anything that already has a fussy, structured or heavily embellished top half gets drowned out by a flat with a big bow or a chunky buckle, you end up looking like two outfits fighting for attention, so keep the shoe simple if the rest of you isn't. They sit best with a straight leg trouser that just grazes the top of the foot, a midi skirt on a day you're actually walking somewhere, or a plain dress where you want the shoe to disappear rather than make a statement. Birthday lunches, work drinks that start at six and might run late, any wedding where the reception's on grass, a normal Wednesday, they cover an enormous amount of ground without ever once asking anything of you.
I'd rather own three good pairs of flats than one pair of heels I wear twice and regret both times.