Hold a ballet flat in your hand before you buy it and bend the sole. If it doesn't flex back easily, put it down, because that stiffness never softens the way you hope it will, it just rubs your heel raw for three weeks and then sits in the hallway unworn. I learned that one properly, a cheap pair that looked perfect in the shop mirror and then ate the back of both heels on a short walk to a friend's house, plasters and all.
They're not the right shoe for distance or for pavement that's wet, uneven or steep, there's no cushioning to speak of and the sole has about as much grip as a sheet of paper once it's a bit worn. If you're on your feet all day, or walking somewhere with no real pavement, you'll regret them by lunchtime. Where they do work is the in between bits, the office, the lunch out, the day that's mostly sitting with some standing mixed in, the kind of day where you want to look finished without your feet complaining about it.
Colour wise, I've gone off bright shades for these because scuffs show up fast on anything pale or saturated, and the toe is the first bit to go. A soft nude, a dark navy or a proper black hide knocks and scrapes far better, and a deep red or burgundy does the same job with a bit more personality. Patent in a dark colour is forgiving too, though it shows every crease where the foot bends, which some women mind more than others.
The difference between a flat that lasts and one that doesn't is almost always in what you can't see until you've had them a month. A proper leather or suede upper moves with your foot and keeps its shape, where a cheap synthetic one creases hard across the toe and never relaxes. Check the inside of the shoe too, a decent one has some padding or a lining that won't bunch up under your toes after an hour, and the stitching round the edge should be even, not glued looking. Press on the heel of the sole in the shop, if it's rock hard it'll stay rock hard.
Before you pay, check the two flats actually match in shape, I've had a pair where one was a fraction narrower than the other and only noticed once I'd walked in them. Check the inner sole for any seam that sits right under the ball of your foot, because that's the one that'll announce itself by the second wear, not the first. If there's a bow or buckle, give it a tug, cheap glue work comes away after a few months in a bag.
Keep a soft brush or a dry cloth to hand and wipe them down after a dusty day out, dirt ground into the seams is what ages them fastest.