The moment it clicked was swapping a tote for a proper laptop bag before a train journey with a connection I had about nine minutes to make. Everything stayed where it was supposed to be, the laptop didn't slide into my ribs when I ran, and I got to the platform without once checking my bag was still doing up. That's the whole pitch, really. It's not glamorous, it's just a bag that behaves.
It's the wrong choice if you want one bag for everything. A dedicated laptop bag is built around a rectangle, so it doesn't flex for an impulse buy of shopping or a change of shoes the way a slouchy tote does, and if you're someone who likes to carry light and loose, the structure will drive you mad. It's also overkill if your laptop lives on a desk and only moves house once a year. Buy for the carrying you actually do, not the carrying you imagine doing.
How it wears depends almost entirely on what it's made of, and this is where I've learned the hard way. A stiff faux leather looks sharp on day one and then creases unevenly at the fold points within a couple of months, in a way that reads as tired rather than lived in. Canvas and coated cotton age better, they soften at the handles and go slightly grubby at the base in a way that feels earned. Whatever it is, wipe the base down now and then, the floor of trains and offices is filthier than anyone admits, and keep it away from direct heat when it's wet or the lining can warp.
Before you buy, feel the handle drop with your coat on, not just your jumper, because an inch makes the difference between comfortably over the shoulder and strangling your armpit. Check the laptop sleeve is padded on both sides, not just the back, some only protect the side facing away from your body, which is a strange choice given the number of people who bash a bag against a desk leg. Look at the zip pulls too, small chunky ones you can grab with gloves on beat the dainty metal tags that look nice and do nothing in December. And check there's a separate pocket for cables, chargers tangling with your phone and keys is a special kind of morning stress nobody needs before nine.
This is for anyone who carries a laptop most days and is tired of pretending a regular bag can do that job properly.
If you're after more of the same, head to phone bags.