Hold it up to the light before anything else. That's the test I give any silver ring now, because I bought a lovely looking band years ago that turned my finger faintly green by lunchtime, and that's not silver, that's silver plated over something with ambitions. A proper one should feel slightly heavier than you expect, cool against your skin for a second longer than cheap metal does, and the inside should be smooth, not stamped rough where the edges catch on gloves.
Sizing is where most of the disappointment happens, and it's rarely the ring's fault. Fingers swell in heat, shrink in the cold, and change through the day, so try a ring on in the afternoon if you can, not first thing. Go for a snug fit over the knuckle, not a loose one, because silver stretches slightly with wear and a ring that spins freely in the shop will be sliding off into the washing up within a month. If you're between sizes, size up rather than down for anything you'll wear daily, you can always get a jeweller to pinch it in slightly, but widening a ring that's too tight is a bigger job. Watch for bands that are thin enough to bend out of round, especially stacking rings, a decent one holds its shape even after you've tugged it off over moisturised hands for the hundredth time. Hallmarks matter here, a proper stamp tells you what you're actually wearing, and the absence of one is worth asking about before you buy.
The difference between a ring that lasts and one that turns up in a drawer after six weeks usually comes down to finish and weight rather than anything flashy. A well made silver ring keeps its shine with the odd polish, not a special cloth bought separately and a prayer. Cheap plating goes patchy at the edges first, usually where the ring meets your other fingers, and no amount of polishing brings that back. Soldered joins should be invisible, not a visible seam you can catch a nail on. If there's a stone set in, check the setting doesn't have sharp little prongs waiting to snag your jumper.
Silver isn't the one to reach for if you're swimming regularly, working with harsh chemicals, or you tarnish things just by looking at them, some skin chemistry is genuinely unkind to it. It sits oddly against anything heavily gold toned, mixing metals works for some, but a thin silver band next to a chunky gold cuff usually looks like an oversight rather than a choice.
Reach for silver when you want something that looks a bit more considered than costume jewellery without the faff or expense of gold, day to day, through most of the year, hands and weather allowing.