You can spot the good summer boot outfit from across a car park. One woman's ankle boots sit neatly at the narrowest part of her leg with a hem that actually meets them. The other has a bootcut jean bunching over the top like a sock that's given up, or a dress that stops at exactly the wrong inch and makes the whole thing look accidental. Same boots, completely different verdict.
Colour is where most of this gets decided before you even think about shape. Tan, a soft honey brown or a worn in chestnut will go with more of what's already hanging in your cupboard than black ever does in summer, because black against bare legs in June can look like you're dressed for a different season entirely. A pale leather, the sort that reads almost biscuit, works brilliantly against washed denim and white and does the heavy lifting on a dress that would otherwise look like it needed a cardigan. Black still has a place, I'm not banning it, but check it against your actual skin tone in daylight near a window, not under shop lighting, because summer boots on bare legs show up every undertone clash a dark winter boot would hide under tights.
For occasions, this is a shoulder season shoe more than a high summer one. Think an evening that's turned cooler than the forecast promised, a festival field, a city break where the pavements are uneven and sandals won't survive the walking, or a wedding guest outfit where you want height without a heel you'll be begging to take off by nine. Full, sweaty, thirty degree days are sandal weather and no boot is going to argue its way out of that.
If you own none of these, start with an ankle boot in a mid brown leather with a small heel, nothing dramatic, something you can walk a genuine distance in without wincing. Try it with your trousers on, not alone, and check where the hem sits against the boot, standing and walking, because that's the detail that decides whether the outfit reads as deliberate or like you got dressed in the dark. A slouchy boot that folds down at the ankle is the next one to add, it does florals and midi skirts in a way the structured version never quite manages.
Pair them with a slip skirt, a loose white shirt, straight leg jeans rolled once at the ankle, or a simple cotton dress that needs something other than a flat sandal to feel finished. Tomorrow morning I'd put mine with a linen shirt dress and nothing else complicated, and call it done.