Nobody tells you in the shop that a good pair of summer loafers will crease across the toe within a fortnight and that this is the point, not a flaw. The leather softens, the shape gives slightly at the ball of the foot, and what felt faintly stiff on day one starts to move with you rather than against you. The ones that still look showroom perfect after two months of actual wear are usually the ones that never got worn properly at all.
Getting the fit right matters more with loafers than with almost any other summer shoe, because there's no lace or strap to rescue a mistake. You want them snug enough at the heel that they don't slip when you walk, but with enough room across the toes that you can wiggle them without feeling the leather pinch. Do the backwards walk test in the shop, a few steps heel first, and if your foot lifts out of the back even slightly, go down half a size before you go up one, loafers that are too big never tighten, they just slap. Watch the material at the inner ankle bone too, stiff leather there will rub before lunch and no amount of plasters fixes a badly shaped last. They sit oddly with anything that bunches at the ankle, wide cropped trousers with a lot of fabric pooling over the top look untidy rather than relaxed, and thick white socks under them read as a joke that wasn't intended, bare ankle or a very fine no show sock is the better call. I'd also leave them at home for anything involving long walking on uneven ground, that flat sole with no real tread is fine for pavement and train platforms, less fine for a gravel path or a wet hillside, where they turn treacherous fast.
Where they do the most good is the stretch of the year when it's too warm for proper shoes but you still want to look like you dressed on purpose, a lunch out, an office with no real dress code, a city break where you're on your feet all day but don't want to be in trainers. Tan and a soft mid brown are the shades that go with almost everything you already own and show scuffs the least, which matters because loafers do get scuffed, that's just the job they do. White looks wonderful for about three wears before it looks tired, and I'd think twice before anything metallic unless you're genuinely prepared to treat it as a going out shoe rather than a daily one. A proper navy pair is the one I'd suggest trying before you assume you only want tan, it goes with more than you'd expect and hides the summer dust better than black does.