Black sandals have a reputation for being the boring but correct answer, the thing you buy because you need it rather than because you want it, and for once the reputation is fair. I own more pairs than I'd admit under oath, and the ones I actually wear are not the ones I got excited about in the shop. They're the flat ones that don't pinch across the top of my foot, which on a size eight with a high instep is a smaller category than you'd think.
If you've got none, start with a flat or barely raised sandal with a simple strap across the front and an ankle or buckle closure, nothing architectural. It's the version that goes under a hem without an argument, and on me a straight leg trouser needs the strap to sit low enough not to cut across the ankle bone, which rules out more styles than I'd like. The difference between a good one and a sad one is mostly in the sole and the leather. A proper leather upper softens and moulds within a couple of wears, whereas the stiffer synthetic ones keep their shop shape and dig in at the same spot every single time, usually just where my little toe would like some privacy. Check the footbed too, a thin, flat slab of nothing will have you aching by four o'clock, while a touch of contoured padding earns its forgiveness by hour six. Stitching should look deliberate, not like it was done in a hurry on a Friday, and any buckle or hardware should move without catching on the leather. Cheap ones often look identical to good ones on the shelf, which is the annoying part, you only find out the truth after a full day on your feet.
On an ordinary week these sit under a linen trouser, under a plain midi skirt, or with bare legs and a simple dress where you want the shoe to disappear rather than make a statement. I wear mine with a denim skirt more than anything else, mostly because it's the one combination where I've never once looked down and winced. They're a three season shoe really, from late spring through to early autumn, and they do dressed down daytime things best, a market, a lunch, a wander round somewhere with uneven paving that stilettos would never survive. By midsummer evening they can go a little dressier if the rest of the outfit is doing some work.
Reach for them when you want to stop thinking about your feet and get on with the day.