I used to buy heeled sandals the way I buy cheap tulips in January, on a whim, because the colour caught me, and then wonder why they let me down within the hour. The ones that did it were a hard, shiny coral pair, gorgeous on the shelf, and by the time I'd walked from the car to a wedding reception the straps had cut a line across the top of my foot like a cheese wire. What put me right was a woman at a trade counter who told me to stop looking at the colour first and look at where the footbed actually bends. Sounds obvious. Took me years.
A good pair of heeled sandals has weight to the sole without being clumpy, and the strap sits where your foot already creases rather than fighting it. That's the whole difference between the coral disaster and the pair I've had for four summers now, a dusty pink with a block heel, which I'd compare to the difference between a florist's rose that's been fed properly and a garage forecourt one that's already dropping petals by the time you get it home. Where heeled sandals come unstuck is in the pairing, not the shoe itself. A busy printed dress wants a plain sandal, otherwise you've got two loud things arguing with each other, your eye doesn't know where to land, a bit like putting dahlias and sweet peas in the same vase and wondering why it looks like a jumble sale. Save the statement strap or the bright colour for something simple, a slip dress, tailored trousers, and let one of them do the talking. They're brilliant from late spring through to September, for anything with a bit of occasion to it, a lunch that matters, a wedding, an evening where you want height without the commitment of a stiletto you'll be carrying home by ten.
They are not an all weather shoe and I wish someone had told me that before I wore a pair across wet cobbles and nearly went down outside a church. Rain, long walks, anything on grass, forget it, your feet will be wrecked and so will the leather if it's a good one. They're also the wrong choice for a long day on your feet with no sitting down, an open strap doesn't support you the way a proper sandal with a covered toe might, and by hour six you'll feel every mile.
What to look for first is the strap placement against your own foot, not the shoe on its own.