Will leather sandals actually hold up to a full summer of proper wear, or are they a nice idea that falls apart by August? A decent pair will, and it's almost always the sole and the stitching that decide which one you've bought, not the bit you can see.
The difference shows up after a few weeks, not on day one. Cheap leather, or leather that's been sprayed and finished within an inch of its life, cracks across the toe post and goes grey at the edges where your foot bends it. Proper leather softens instead, takes on a bit of a patina, and moulds to your foot so the second summer is actually more comfortable than the first. Stitching matters more than people expect from a sandal, because that's what's holding the strap to the sole when you're walking on uneven pavement or hot sand, and glued straps tend to start lifting at the edge within a season, however neat they looked in the shop. The sole itself is worth checking too. A proper leather or rubber sole with some grip will survive wet decking and cobbles, while a thin, slippery sole turns a harbour wall into a hazard. Hardware, if there's a buckle, should feel like it's actually attached to something rather than just threaded through a loop of leather that'll tear the first time you do it up in a hurry.
Once you've got a decent pair, they're not fussy about what they're worn with. They sit happily under a plain cotton dress, look right with wide leg trousers rolled at the ankle, and don't feel wrong even with shorts and a shirt you've had for years. That's the real test of a good sandal, in my opinion, not whether it looks smart in isolation but whether it disappears into whatever you're already wearing, including the slightly crumpled version of yourself at the end of a long day. Tan, a soft brown, or a natural undyed leather are the easiest to live with, because they age well rather than just getting dirty, and they go with every colour you own without you having to think about it. Black is fine too, more useful than people give it credit for, but it shows scuffing on the toe in a way tan doesn't.
Mine have been in a bag at the bottom of a wardrobe through a whole winter, come out creased across the strap, and straightened out within a day of being worn. That's the proper test, not how they look brand new.
For something along similar lines, see black sandals.